AJET: Review Form

Australasian Journal of Educational Technology Review Form

Confidential

For an MS Word version of this form please open [http://www.ascilite.org.au/ajet/about/ref/ajet-reviewform.doc]

Manuscript filename: Reviewer:

Title:

Date Sent: Date Due: 3 weeks

Articles under review and completed Review Forms are confidential
and the contents are not to be revealed to other persons.

A. Overview

Please rate each item by typing letter x in the appropriate box Poor Fair Good Very good

1. Importance and interest of topic to AJET readers. Originality, contribution to humanity's stock of knowledge, quality of creative work.

2. Quality of literature review and consistency with the relevant literature.

3. Clarity of the goals of the research or development effort.

4. Adequacy of the research method and accuracy of data analysis.

5. Presentation and interpretation of findings, inferences and conclusions.

6. Inclusion of appropriate implications for practice and/or policy.

7. Grammatical construction; writing style; clarity of ideas, use of non-sexist language.

B. Paper Critique

Please provide a brief critique on the next page (after the page break below). As a minimum, please provide a one sentence to one paragraph summary of the reasons for your recommendation in C below. Your critique should assist the Editors to provide formative feedback to the authors. This feedback is anonymous and usually combines comments from yourself and one or two other reviewers.

C. Recommendation (type letter x in the appropriate box)

Accept

Accept with minor revisions

Accept subject to major revisions

Invite resubmission for a new review after major revisions

Reject

Please return the completed Form as an email attachment (please do not change the Form's filename) addressed to: (one of the following will be specified in the version of the form that each reviewer receives):

Associate Professor Catherine McLoughlin
School of Education (ACT)
Australian Catholic University
PO Box 256, Dickson ACT 2602, Australia
Tel: 61 2 6209 1100 Fax 61 2 6209 1185
Email: c.mcloughlin@signadou.acu.edu.au Dr Roger Atkinson
Unit 5, 202 Coode Street
Como WA 6152, Australia
Tel: +61 8 9367 1133
Email: rjatkinson@bigpond.com

Reviewer's Comments

[ MS Word version of this form ] [ Advice for authors] [ Panel of Reviewers] [ References ] [ About AJET ]

This URL: http://www.ascilite.org.au/ajet/about/ref/review-form.html
Last revision: 2 July 2008. HTML: Roger Atkinson, AJET Production Editor [rjatkinson@bigpond.com]

Manuscript filename:	Reviewer:
Title:
Date Sent:	Date Due: 3 weeks
Articles under review and completed Review Forms are confidential and the contents are not to be revealed to other persons.

	Please rate each item by typing letter x in the appropriate box	Poor	Fair	Good	Very good
1.	Importance and interest of topic to AJET readers. Originality, contribution to humanity's stock of knowledge, quality of creative work.
2.	Quality of literature review and consistency with the relevant literature.
3.	Clarity of the goals of the research or development effort.
4.	Adequacy of the research method and accuracy of data analysis.
5.	Presentation and interpretation of findings, inferences and conclusions.
6.	Inclusion of appropriate implications for practice and/or policy.
7.	Grammatical construction; writing style; clarity of ideas, use of non-sexist language.

Accept
Accept with minor revisions
Accept subject to major revisions
Invite resubmission for a new review after major revisions
Reject